8 Best Colognes for Teenage Guys, According to a Fragrance Snob

For decades now, young people have made CK One a go-to. Now this updated version of the iconic scent is here to seduce a new generation. Concentrated green notes of bergamot, geranium, and moss intensify the original, bringing to mind fresh water and mountainous woods. I’ve learned that a little goes a long way; one or two spritzes should be plenty to last an entire school day. And yes, like all the brand’s scents, it’s unisex—but I see this appealing more to guys.

Family: Fresh
Notes: Bergamot, black pepper, mint, geranium, musk, moss, sandalwood
Sizes: 1.7 oz., 3.4 oz.

While it’s the most expensive pick on this list, Replica’s By the Fireplace has gone viral on TikTok many times over, earning droves of new fans in the process. Why? It’s warm and wintry, using clove, chestnut, and vanilla to evoke a snowy evening spent by a fire. It’s just the right strength for teenage guys; it’s strong, but it won’t overpower an entire car or classroom. This scent isn’t for everyone (including cologne beginners), but it’ll please guys who like to stand out from the crowd.

Family: Woody
Notes: Pink pepper, clove oil, chestnut, orange flower, vanilla
Sizes: 1 oz., 3.4 oz.

Originally launched in 2002, Fierce has had leagues of teenage fans for over two decades. While the woody fragrance can feel generic, that’s because it’s basically the blueprint for teen-oriented scents, layering marine notes with earthier sandalwood and vetiver. Consider this a gateway scent to the heavier, more expensive stuff like Montblanc, Hugo Boss, and Prada. The minimalist bottle leaves a little to be desired, especially since many cheaper options offer cooler designs, but the fragrance itself still shines.

Family: Woody
Notes: Marine accord, fir, lemon, sage, sandalwood, vetiver
Sizes: 1 oz., 1.7 oz., 3.4 oz., 6.7 oz.

American Eagle’s under $50 cologne is another great entry-level pick, offering a fresh, woody scent that’s completely age-appropriate. Juicy pear and floral lavender add some bright energy to the clean, refreshing vibe—essentially the exact opposite of the musk-heavy deodorant sprays that haunt high school locker rooms. I recommend it for younger guys who have some time before graduating to try something a little smarter.

Family: Fresh
Notes: Pear, lavender buds, amber woods
Sizes: 1.7 oz.

A popular starter high-end cologne, Versace Dylan Blue is aquatic and woody—pretty much exactly what you’d imagine if I asked you to dream up a men’s cologne. Green notes of bergamot and patchouli keep things fresh, while a deeper, aromatic base of musk, incense, and tonka bean grounds the lighter side. It’s also hard to overspray, which teenagers tend to do. (See also: Versace Eros and Versace Pour Homme.)

Family: Fresh
Notes: Bergamot, grapefruit, black pepper, patchouli, violet leaves, musk, saffron, incense, tonka bean
Sizes: 1.7 oz, 3.4 oz., 6.7 oz.

Fragrance people recommend Ralph Lauren Polo Red for young men, and I completely agree; it’s refined, but with a spicy, fruity edge that feels youthful. Grapefruit, saffron, and sage go big on the citrus and spice, making this an energizing, athletic pick that’s a perfect entryway into the world of cologne. It could last longer, but it’s affordable enough that a few extra sprays throughout the day won’t set you back too much.

Family: Woody
Notes: Grapefruit, lavender, saffron, lemon, sage, redwood
Sizes: 2.5 oz., 4.2 oz., 6.7 oz.